EPISODE 18SOURCE LIST
The Town That Dreaded Sundown: The True Story of the Texarkana Phantom Killer
Unsolved Case
No one was ever charged with these murders, and the case remains officially unsolved. Youell Swinney was never tried for them; what this page lists about him is what the record shows or what investigators believed, not a finding of guilt.
This page lists the sources behind the claims made in this episode, tiered by how well-established each one is. Confirmed facts come from court records, police reports, or multiple independent contemporaneous news sources. Disputed items have conflicting accounts. Single-source claims rest on one account with no corroboration — treat them accordingly.
Confirmed court & multi-source
Disputed conflicting accounts
Single source uncorroborated
Confirmed Facts
31 items
Confirmed
Four attacks took place between February 22 and May 3, 1946, in and around Texarkana, on both the Texas and Arkansas sides of the line. They left five people dead and three wounded.
Confirmed
The victims were Jimmy Hollis and Mary Jeanne Larey (both survived, February 22); Richard Griffin and Polly Ann Moore (killed, March 24); Paul Martin and Betty Jo Booker (killed, April 14); and Virgil Starks (killed) and Katie Starks (survived), May 3.
Confirmed
On February 22, 1946, a masked man in a hood approached Hollis and Larey as they sat parked on a back road, hit Hollis over the head with a pistol hard enough to fracture his skull, ordered Larey to run, caught her, knocked her down and sexually assaulted her. She ran about half a mile to a house; Hollis reached the road and flagged a passing driver. Both survived. Sheriff Bill Presley arrived with three Texarkana patrolmen.
Confirmed
On March 24, 1946, Richard Griffin, 29, and Polly Ann Moore, 17, were found shot dead in Griffin’s car on a lane off U.S. Highway 67. Each had been shot once in the back of the head with a .32-caliber pistol.
Confirmed
On April 14, 1946, Betty Jo Booker, 15, played saxophone at a dance at the VFW club with a local band. She told the band member driving the girls home that she was waiting for a friend, Paul Martin, who would take her to a slumber party at a girlfriend’s house; about 1:30 a.m. she left with him. Martin was found shot dead at about 6:30 a.m.; Booker was found about five hours later, roughly two miles away. (Sources differ on Martin’s age, so the episode does not give it.)
Confirmed
The Griffin–Moore and Martin–Booker murders were committed with the same .32-caliber pistol. The Starks attack used a different, .22-caliber weapon.
Confirmed
The “Phantom” nickname originated with Texarkana Gazette editors in mid-April 1946, after the Martin–Booker murders and before the Starks attack.
Confirmed
On May 3, 1946, shortly before 9 p.m., Virgil Starks, 37, who farmed and ran a welding shop, was shot twice in the back of the head through a closed window of his farmhouse about ten miles northeast of Texarkana while he sat reading. His wife, Katie, came to see what had happened and was shot twice in the face through the same window. She survived, reached a neighbor’s house on foot, and was questioned by the sheriff in the operating room.
Confirmed
Panic followed the Starks attack: by May 5 forty-seven officers were working the case, and Texarkana stores sold out of locks, guns, ammunition and window coverings within a day.
Confirmed
The FBI Laboratory concluded that the Starks cartridge cases were fired from “an auto loading weapon similar to the caliber .22 Colt Woodsman pistol.” The county sheriff, W. E. Davis, had first believed the weapon was an automatic rifle, and a newspaper repeated that as fact days later.
Confirmed
Dr. Anthony Lapalla, a psychiatrist at the federal prison in Texarkana, said in a Texarkana Gazette interview published in May 1946 that the same man had committed all the crimes. His reasoning, as both Newton and Presley report it, was that the killer knew the outlying roads were heavily patrolled and so would strike somewhere else. (The same interview contained racial characterizations of suspects; the episode does not repeat them.)
Confirmed
Newton reports that the Starks case is left off several Texas Ranger documents listing the Phantom’s victims. He does not name the documents, and he notes that the FBI’s file consistently includes the Starks couple.
Confirmed
After Peggy Swinney’s arrest on June 28, 1946, an FBI agent and an Arkansas state police officer searched the couple’s lodging and found a tan shirt. Delivered to the FBI Laboratory on July 15, 1946, it was examined to “endeavor to definitely determine” whether faded writing inside the collar read “STARK” or “STARR.” Slitting open the two pockets, the examiner found sand, magnetic slag balls and brown human hair in the seams.
Confirmed
The Laboratory could not say how long the name had been on the shirt. When the sheriff asked again, J. Edgar Hoover’s reply was: “Impossible to determine age of laundry mark on shirt.” Newton, working from the same file, reports that analysts could not decide between STARK and STARR.
Confirmed
The FBI was told the shirt also bore a commercial laundry code, and that a dungaree jacket “bearing the same laundry mark” was the known clothing of Youell Swinney.
Confirmed
On the slag, the Laboratory wrote that it was “similar to those found in grinding and welding operations” and that its presence was “thought to be very significant.” Slag balls were present in all nine soil and metal samples the sheriff collected from Virgil Starks’s welding shop. On the sand, the Laboratory found “differences” that “prevent saying in court that the specimens could have come from the same source,” and said the comparison “would probably carry very little weight.”
Confirmed
Some head hair in the pocket seams was, in the Laboratory’s words, similar enough to Virgil Starks’s hair to have come from the same source and “could not have come from the suspect.” The examiner’s opinion was that the hair came “from both the victim and suspect or from still another person who has hair with similar characteristics.”
Confirmed
Shown the shirt, Katie Starks said it was her husband’s and pointed to a place on the front she remembered mending. The next day or so she said she could not be sure, knowing her word could send a man to the electric chair. This is the account of Arkansas State Police officer Max Tackett, as reported by both Newton and Presley.
Confirmed
Presley reports that Swinney “was known to steal clothing” and had a suitcase full of clothing when he was arrested.
Confirmed
Peggy Swinney, then 21, married Youell Swinney in Shreveport, Louisiana, on June 28, 1946. She was his legal wife, not a common-law wife. The same day she returned to Texarkana, went to a stolen Plymouth, and was arrested by Arkansas State Police.
Confirmed
Youell Swinney, 29, was a career car thief and counterfeiter.
Source: Wikipedia — Youell Swinney
Confirmed
Peggy was questioned by at least a dozen law enforcement officers, by the FBI’s count. On the night of July 25, 1946, she told Sheriff Davis she was with Swinney when he killed Paul Martin and Betty Jo Booker, and she signed a statement on July 26. On July 28, while being driven to Dallas by two sheriffs to find where bloody clothes had been burned, she said the entire story was untrue and that she had made it because she had been “questioned so extensively.” The FBI recorded that the Texarkana, Texas sheriff’s office and the Texas Rangers were “convinced that her statement was untrue.”
Confirmed
In her July 1946 statement Peggy showed investigators the place where she said Swinney had changed out of bloody clothes. An FBI teletype says it “is the same point where the Martin boy’s address book was found.” Both Presley and Newton report that Sheriff Presley had found the address book himself and kept it secret, even from other investigators.
Confirmed
On November 22, 1946, at Austin, a Texas Department of Public Safety polygraph interview “indicated that she was telling the truth at all times,” though Sheriff Presley told the FBI he did not have one hundred percent faith in it.
Confirmed
On February 19, 1947, Peggy signed a new statement with her parents in the room. The same day she wrote them a letter from jail, intercepted by the jail, saying the officers “will believe a lie” and that Swinney “was not the one.” She had retracted again by February 26. In the FBI agents’ own assessment, it was hard to see how she could know what she knew unless she had been there, but she had been interviewed by at least a dozen officers and it was possible she had picked up the information from them.
Confirmed
In a March 4, 1947 FBI memo, neither Swinney could establish where they were between the morning of April 13 and the evening of April 14, 1946. Youell said they went from Dallas to Austin and San Antonio but could “furnish no place in which his presence there can be established.” Peggy said they went to Texarkana and stayed until about 7 a.m., but could not furnish places that established it either. Investigators believed Swinney had owned a pistol; see Single-Source Claims.
Confirmed
Fingerprints of both Swinneys were compared with the latent prints in the case in 1946 and again in 1948, without an identification.
Confirmed
Swinney was never charged with the murders. On February 12, 1947 he was sentenced to life as a habitual criminal on a car-theft charge, and he was released in 1973 after a habeas corpus ruling invalidated a prior conviction used to establish his habitual-offender status. In March 1947 he told the FBI his wife’s account was “a complete lie.” He died in 1994, denying any involvement. Under the spousal-testimony rule of the era, Peggy could not be compelled to testify against him.
Confirmed
Henry Booker “Doodie” Tennison, 18, who had been in the same high-school band as Betty Jo Booker, died by suicide on November 4, 1948 and left a note confessing to the Martin–Booker and Starks murders. Investigators found no fingerprint match and no confirmed access to a weapon, and a friend gave him an alibi for the night of the Starks murder.
Confirmed
Historian James Presley’s 2014 book, drawing on the files of his uncle, Sheriff Bill Presley, makes the most detailed documented argument that Swinney was the killer; Texas Monthly called it “as convincing an argument as anyone is ever likely to make,” while noting the case it builds is circumstantial.
Confirmed
The case remains officially unsolved and has been described by the Texas Department of Public Safety as the state’s “number one unsolved murder case.”
Disputed / Theories
6 items
Disputed
Was Youell Swinney the Phantom Killer? The strongest documented case (Presley, and the lifelong belief of investigators Max Tackett and Bill Presley) rests on Peggy Swinney’s statements, one scene detail that matched, a shirt whose meaning is itself contested, and an unrecovered pistol. Against it: no murder charge was ever filed, no fingerprint or bullet-to-weapon link was established in the sources reviewed, Swinney denied it until his death, and Peggy’s account changed repeatedly before she retracted it.
Disputed
One killer, or two? The Starks attack used a different caliber of weapon and a different method (a married couple at home, shot through a window, with no sexual assault) from the lovers’-lane attacks. The sources reviewed do not settle whether one person committed all four attacks. Positions on one side: Dr. Lapalla, Presley, the FBI’s file, which lists all the cases together. On the other: Sheriff Davis, who in the first days would not call the Starks shooting definitely connected, officers who thought it did not fit the pattern, and the Ranger documents Newton describes.
Disputed
Does the shirt tie Swinney to the Starks farmhouse? For: it was found among his things weeks after the shooting; its collar name is one letter from the victim’s; the Laboratory called the welding slag “very significant”; hair in the seams was similar to Virgil Starks’s and, per the Laboratory, could not be Swinney’s; Katie Starks’s first reaction was that it was her husband’s. Against: the FBI could not date the mark or settle STARK versus STARR; a Texarkana laundry attributed the mark to a customer named Starr; Katie Starks withdrew her identification; the Laboratory said the sand comparison could not support a same-source claim in court; the shirt carried the same laundry code as Swinney’s own jacket, and Swinney habitually stole clothing; no fingerprint match.
Disputed
Was Peggy Swinney in the car because she was there, or because she had been told? For: she took investigators to the spot where the address book was found, a detail the sheriff had kept secret, and the FBI agents wrote that it was hard to see how she knew unless she had been present. Against: in the same paragraph they noted a dozen officers had interviewed her and she might have picked it up from them; she retracted on July 28, 1946 and again in February 1947; the Texas Rangers and sheriff’s office were “convinced” her statement was untrue at one point; her fingerprints, like Swinney’s, were compared with the Martin–Booker latents and found “not identical.”
Disputed
Were the Swinneys in Texarkana on the night of April 13–14, 1946? Peggy’s statements say yes. Youell told the FBI they went from Dallas to Austin and San Antonio. In March 1947 the FBI recorded that neither version could be established by any place or witness. A December 1946 newspaper report that a couple slept under a bridge near San Antonio is, per Presley, police misinformation, not a verified alibi.
Disputed
Was H.B. Tennison the killer? His 1948 suicide note confessed to the Martin–Booker and Starks murders. It was not corroborated by fingerprints, he had a friend’s alibi for at least the Starks night, and investigators found no sign he could get a gun. Secondary accounts name him as a persistent alternative to Swinney, but a weaker one.
Single-Source Claims
6 items
Single source
Jimmy Hollis was struck twice on the head with the pistol. Skull fractures are confirmed; the count of “twice” appears in Wikipedia, which cites Newton p. 4, but did not surface in Newton’s text on that page.
Single source
The sheriff arrived with three officers within about half an hour of the February 22 attack. The three patrolmen are confirmed (Newton p. 5); the half-hour figure rests on Wikipedia’s citation of Newton p. 6 and did not surface in Newton’s text.
Single source
A Texarkana laundry manager looked at the mark on the shirt and said it belonged to a customer named Starr, and at the time the laundry’s records showed that code as hers. Years later the deputy who carried the shirt, Tillman Johnson, concluded the laundryman had missed a faded K, by which time the laundry’s records no longer existed. This rests on Presley’s account of Johnson’s recollection; the FBI’s own STARK-or-STARR question fits it, but no second source was found.
Single source
Investigators believed Swinney sold a pistol, a .32 or .38 Colt-type automatic, at a dice game at a railroad work camp in Oklahoma after the murders. The account comes from Tackett (quoted by Newton) and a railroad special agent’s report (summarized by Presley), and the two versions differ on who bought it. The gun was never recovered or test-fired, so it is not a ballistic link.
Single source
In her July 26, 1946 statement Peggy Swinney also blamed Swinney for the Starks shooting, giving a personal grudge as the reason. This comes from a single FBI teletype summary, and she retracted the whole statement two days later. The details of the grudge are not repeated here.
Single source
Presley reports that at a hearing years later (Swinney’s 1970s habeas proceeding), testimony was that the murders were never presented to a grand jury for two reasons, one being that Peggy could not be made to testify against her husband. Swinney’s lawyer argued the real reason was that the state did not have the evidence. This rests on Presley’s description of the testimony, and the witness’s identity is not certain from the text reviewed.