EPISODE 17SOURCE LIST
The Circleville Letters
Unresolved Case
Paul Freshour was convicted of attempted murder in 1983 for the booby trap. No one has ever been charged with writing the Circleville letters, and who wrote them remains officially unresolved. This page does not settle that question, and neither did the episode.
This page lists the sources behind the claims made in this episode, tiered by how well-established each one is. Confirmed facts come from court records, police reports, or multiple independent contemporaneous news sources. Disputed items have conflicting accounts. Single-source claims rest on one account with no corroboration — treat them accordingly.
Confirmed court & multi-source
Disputed conflicting accounts
Single source uncorroborated
Confirmed Facts
15
Confirmed
Beginning in the spring of 1977, anonymous handwritten letters began arriving in mailboxes in Circleville, Ohio. The first ones accused school bus driver Mary Gillispie and school superintendent Gordon Massie of having an affair. No source has ever established that the affair was real. It was the letters' accusation, nothing more.
Confirmed
The letters were written in block capitals, carried no return address, and were mostly postmarked Columbus. Over nearly two decades they reached hundreds of recipients, including Mary's husband Ron, other residents, local businesses, government offices, and newspapers.
Confirmed
One letter to Ron Gillispie read: "Gillispie, you have had 2 weeks and done nothing. Admit the truth and inform the school board." After Ron's death, a letter to Mary read: "Everyone knows what you have done. If you don't believe us, just make them mad and find out for yourself."
Confirmed
On August 19, 1977, Ron Gillispie received a phone call at home. Who called and what was said have never been made public. He told his children he was going to confront the letter writer, took a .22 revolver, and drove off. His truck left the road and hit a tree not far from home, and he was killed. The revolver had been fired once, and no one has ever explained when, where, or at what. The coroner ruled the death an accident. His blood alcohol was reported at roughly twice the legal limit.
Confirmed
People who knew Ron said he was not a heavy drinker, and several family members, including his sisters Janet Cassady and June Whitehead and his brother-in-law Paul Freshour, questioned whether the crash was a simple accident.
Confirmed
At about 3:30 p.m. on February 7, 1983, Mary Gillispie found a homemade, hand-lettered sign with an obscene remark about her daughter posted at the intersection of Scioto-Darby Road and Five Points Pike on her bus route. She pulled it down, put the sign, its board and a small box attached to it on the bus, and finished her route. At home she opened the glued box and found a loaded .25-caliber pistol, rigged to fire when the sign was pulled. She took it to the sheriff.
Confirmed
The trap gun was traced to Paul Freshour, Mary's brother-in-law. Freshour was married to Ron Gillispie's sister, Karen Sue. He said the gun had been stolen weeks earlier and failed police polygraph testing. Karen Sue, who was divorcing him at the time, told police she had found torn-up letter drafts in their home.
Confirmed
Freshour's attempted-murder trial began on October 24, 1983. He was convicted and received the maximum sentence of 7 to 25 years. He was never charged with writing the anonymous letters.
Confirmed
Anonymous letters kept arriving in Circleville throughout Freshour's imprisonment, including some addressed to him. Prison officials said that at times he had no access to pen or paper and was searched repeatedly. How the letters continued has never been officially explained.
Confirmed
Before filming a segment on the case in December 1993, the TV show Unsolved Mysteries received a postcard reading "Forget Circleville, Ohio … if you come to Ohio, you el sickos will pay," signed "The Circleville Writer." The crew filmed anyway. Freshour, nearing parole, was interviewed and asked for the letters to be reinvestigated: "Reopen the letter part of it."
Confirmed
Freshour was paroled in 1994, the same year the letters stopped arriving.
Confirmed
Paul Freshour died on June 28, 2012, at age 70, still maintaining that he did not write the letters.
Confirmed
In 2021, CBS's 48 Hours (correspondent Erin Moriarty) revisited the case. Forensic document examiner Beverley East compared 49 of the anonymous letters with Freshour's known writing, including a personal letter to a friend. She pointed to an unusual capital "G" that "looks like a six" and a recurring 3/2 ambiguity in zip codes, and concluded: "I would say one person wrote all of these. And the one person is this person. Paul Freshour."
Confirmed
Former FBI profiler Mary Ellen O'Toole reviewed 98 letters for the same reporting and doubted Freshour was the writer. She described the author as "callous," driven by power and control, and "not a highly educated person," while Freshour held a master's degree. She suggested the booby trap "may have been done by somebody else who took advantage of the situation," and said she could not explain the letters sent during his imprisonment.
Confirmed
The Pickaway County Sheriff's Office considers the attempted-murder case closed. No one has ever been charged with writing the letters, and who wrote them remains officially unresolved.
Disputed / Theories
7
Disputed
Did Paul Freshour write the letters? This has never been proven, and he was never charged with it. Beverley East says the handwriting points to him, and Mary Ellen O'Toole disputes this based on the writer's apparent education level and personality profile. The two experts worked from overlapping, but not identical, sets of letters.
Disputed
How did letters keep arriving while Freshour was in prison? The competing explanations are that he had an accomplice or someone else carried the campaign on in his style, that he was never the author, or that prison restrictions were looser than officials described. No source resolves this.
Disputed
How did Ron Gillispie die? The official ruling is an accidental crash with elevated blood alcohol. Family members suspected foul play because of the timing. No official reopening or contrary finding has been located.
Disputed
Was the Gillispie–Massie affair real? Sources consistently report it only as the letters' accusation. No source independently confirms or denies it.
Disputed
How much weight does the 1983 handwriting evidence carry? Some of the samples Freshour gave the sheriff were copied from actual Circleville letters, and others were dictated. The jury heard how the samples were taken. The defense-retained examiner testified that he set the copied pages aside, worked from the dictated pages and Freshour's personnel-file writing, saw indications of disguise, and found nothing pointing to a different writer, but he did not give a flat identification. A 2026 retrospective argues the collection method compromised the evidence. The 1986 appeals decision describes the evidence as establishing that Freshour wrote the letters.
Disputed
Were Freshour's fingerprints on letters mailed after his arrest? Researcher Marie Mayhew, reviewing the case file for 48 Hours, reported his prints on about a dozen letters postmarked while he was in prison. Crime Junkie, citing state crime-lab records, reports prints on 26 letters and envelopes sent after his arrest, a window that includes about eight months he was free on bail. The claim was not raised at trial. Freshour said prints were found on the letters but none were his. The underlying lab reports have not been independently reviewed for this page.
Source: CBS News, "Has the anonymous author of the infamous Circleville letters been unmasked?"; Crime Junkie, "INFAMOUS: Circleville Letters" (episode source list); Paul Freshour, "the full story" (includes 1983 trial transcript excerpts and the 1986 appeals decision; a defendant's own advocacy file)
Disputed
Did Freshour admit to writing some of the letters? According to the sheriff, Freshour admitted on the night of his arrest, after failing polygraph testing, to writing 40 or 50 of the letters while denying the booby trap. Freshour denied ever saying it, and no recording of any admission exists. No reference to it has been found in the trial record.
Single-Source Claims
11
Single source
An early letter to Mary Gillispie reportedly read: "I've been observing your house, and I know you have children."
Source: All That's Interesting
Single source
A letter reportedly told Ron Gillispie that his wife was seeing Massie and that he "should catch them together and kill them both." A separate account describes a demand that Ron end the affair "or die."
Source: All That's Interesting; separately, Historic Mysteries
Single source
Ron and Mary Gillispie reportedly sent letters of their own to the person they suspected, saying they knew who it was and asking that person to stop.
Source: Historic Mysteries
Single source
Some letters reportedly contained vulgar drawings, and the targets reportedly included elected officials.
Source: Historic Mysteries
Single source
Later anonymous letters reportedly accused the county sheriff of covering up Ron Gillispie's death. This is an accusation made by the anonymous writer, and nothing located in the record supports it.
Single source
Mary Gillispie was reportedly away in Florida when Ron died.
Single source
Ron Gillispie's blood-alcohol reading is reported as .16%, roughly twice the legal limit. Ohio's legal limit in 1977 has not been confirmed for this page, so the comparison should be treated as approximate.
Single source
Some accounts date the first letters to 1976. The earliest letters located in the court file are dated March and April 1977, and no earlier letter has been found.
Single source
According to the sheriff's report, Freshour took and failed three or four polygraph examinations. Freshour said he later took three more and passed.
Single source
One secondary source dates Freshour's arrest and conviction to 1984. Most sources give an October 1983 trial and conviction.
Source: All That's Interesting
Single source
Beverley East's certainty is reported with slightly different emphasis across accounts ("swear on the Bible" and "100% sure"). Her methodology was not independently verified in our research. Treat her conclusion as one expert's stated opinion.